Maps | General information (large file!) | Details and features | Specifications | Issue areas | Press release
Methodology | Background paper | The cartographic metaphor | Criteria | How the maps work (large file!)
For Instructors and Students | Importance of Turing debate | For instructors | For students | Protagonist index | FAQS
Commentary and Reviews | Commentary and reviews | Errata and corrections
Action Items | Buy the set of maps | How you can participate in this debate
Examples | View the maps. | Map 1 | Map 2 | Map 3 | Map 4 | Map 5 | Map 6 | Map 7 | (large files!)
MacroVU home page | Send us a message | Project Director's Home Page

Here are the authors represented on the argumentation maps (with the maps and box numbers where their arguments are represented).

(Click on letter to go to anchor.)
A B C D E F G H J K L M N O P Q R S T V W Z

Abelson, Robert, 2­37
Agre, Phillip E., 3­120
Aizawa, Kenneth, 5­30
Allemang, Dean, 5­67
Ammon, K., 7­54
Anantharaman, Thomas, 3­67
Anderson, John, 5­104, 5­107, 5­109
Antony, Louise, 5­67
Antony, Michael, 5­52
Apter, Michael, 2­27
Arbib, Michael, 1­53
Arnheim, Rudolph, 5­86
Augusta, Ada, 1­103
Ayer, A. J., 1­12

Barnden, John, 3­35
Barnes, Eric, 6­41
Barresi, John, 2­51, 2­67, 2­68, 2­105
Bechtel, William, 5­67
Ben-Yami, Hannoch, 4­63
Benacerraf, Paul, 7­8, 7­48, 7­74
Bigelow, Julian, 3­27
Birnbacher, Dieter, 6­57, 6­65, 6­76
Block, Ned, 2­36, 2­38, 2­47, 2­52, 2­81, 2­82, 2­83, 2­84, 2­88, 2­89, 2­90, 2­92, 2­93, 2­94, 2­95, 2­96, 2­97, 2­98, 2­99, 2­100, 2­101, 2­102, 2­103, 2­104, 5­116, 6­33, 6­90, 6­94
Boden, Margaret, 1­44, 1­112, 1­114
Boolos, George, 7­65
Boring, Edwin, 5­83
Bowie, G. Lee, 7­61
Boyer, R. S., 7­56
Braddon­Mitchell, David, 5­48
Bradshaw, Gary, 1­122
Bringsjord, Selmer, 1­27, 1­127, 4­48, 6­35, 6­36, 6­37, 6­42, 7­93, 7­95, 7­96, 7­98, 7­99, 7­100, 7­101, 7­102, 7­103
Brooks, Rodney, 3­108
Buchanan, B. G., 1­124
Burks, Arthur Walter, 7­92
Butler, Keith, 3­7, 5­19, 5­34, 5­56
Button, Graham, 3­4, 3­54

Cam, Philip, 4­42, 4­65
Campbell, Murray, 3­67
Carleton, Lawrence, 2­24, 4­55, 4­70
Carruthers, Peter, 2­62
Chadrasekaran, B., 5­67
Chalmers, David, 1­69, 1­70, 1­71, 1­73, 1­74, 1­75, 1­76, 5­41, 5­50, 6­29, 6­30, 6­31
Chari, C. T. K., 7­35, 7­36
Chater, Nick, 3­15, 3­24, 5­18
Chisholm, Roderick M., 2­87
Chomsky, Noam, 3­56, 6­95
Churchland, Patricia, 4­95, 4­93, 5­7, 5­8
Churchland, Paul, 4­95, 4­93, 5­7, 5­8
Clancey, William, 3­122
Clark, Andy, 5­21, 5­54
Cleland, Carol, 5­67
Clure, G., 1­52
Coder, David, 7­67
Cog Shop, 3­109
Cohen, B., 1­111
Cohen, Harold, 1­111
Cohen, L. Jonathan, 1­25, 4­57, 6­7
Colby, Kenneth, 2­5, 2­35
Cole, David, 4­20, 4­34, 4­44, 4­47, 4­49, 4­50, 4­51, 4­83, 4­84, 7­99
Collins, A., 1­52
Collins, Harry, 1­116, 1­117, 1­123, 3­101
Copeland, Jack, 1­10, 1­13, 1­15, 1­16, 1­80, 2­6, 2­21, 2­22, 2­39, 2­40, 2­41, 2­64, 2­65, 2­70, 2­71, 2­72, 2­73, 2­74,2­75, 2­76, 2­78, 3­8, 4­43, 5­4,5­6
Coulter, Jeff, 3­4, 3­54
Croucher, Monica, 1­55

Danto, Arthur, 1­41, 1­42
Darden, Lindley, 3­62
Darwin, Charles, 7­111
Davis, Martin, 7­30
de La Mettrie, Julien Offray, 7­106, 7­117
den Uyl, Marten, 5­61
Dennett, Daniel, 1­45, 2­58, 2­63, 4­15, 4­38, 5­46, 6­22, 6­80, 7­11, 7­24, 7­72
Denning, Peter, 7­32
Descartes, René, 6­82, 7­105, 7­112, 7­116
Dewey, John, 3­38
Djerassi, C., 1­124
Double, Richard, 4­21, 4­23, 4­24, 4­72, 4­99
Doyle, Jon, 7­25
Dretske, Fred, 1­63, 1­65
Dreyfus, Hubert, 3­9, 3­33, 3­37, 3­41, 3­44, 3­49, 3­50, 3­59, 3­63, 3­64,3­65, 3­66, 3­76, 3­78, 3­82, 3­83, 3­88, 3­92, 3­96, 3­99, 3­100, 3­102, 5­9, 5­117, 5­118
Dreyfus, Stuart, 3­44, 5­117, 5­118
Dyer, Michael, 1­46

Engleman, K. H. 7­71

Falkenhainer, Brian, 1­68
Feigenbaum, EdwardA., 1­124, 3­87
Feldman, Jerome, 3­22
Fields, C. A., 4­22
Fisher, John, 4­39, 4­40, 4­41
Fitzpatrick, John, 5­48
Flanagan, Owen, 6­60
Flores, Fernando,3­110, 3­111
Fodor, Jerry, 2­61, 3­14, 3­19, 3­23, 3­53, 3­68, 3­118, 4­8, 4­30, 5­16, 5­17, 5­31, 5­36,5­39, 5­44, 6­39, 6­92, 6­96
Forbus, K., 1­68
Freeman, Walter J., 3­34, 3­36, 5­14, 5­66
French, Robert, 1­69, 1­70, 1­71, 1­73, 1­74, 1­75, 1­76, 2­42, 2­43, 2­44,2­45, 2­46
Frijda, Nico, 1­51

Gelb, Adhémar, 6­84
Gelernter, David, 1­38
Gelernter, H., 1­107
Gentner, D., 1­68
George, Frank H., 7­38
Gibson, James, 3­114
Glymour, Clark, 7­28
Gödel, Kurt, 7­4, 7­5, 7­78, 7­91, 7­120
Goel, Ashok, 5­67
Golden, Richard, 5­62
Goldstein, Kurt, 6­84
Good, Irving J., 7­7, 7­10
Greeno, James, 3­116
Gritter, R., 1­124
Guha, R. V., 3­89
Gunderson, Keith, 2­7, 2­8, 2­10, 6­8, 6­18, 6­53, 6­56, 6­70, 6­71
Gurwitsch, Aron, 6­83

Hannah, Patricia, 4­56
Hanson, Stephen José, 5­67
Harnad, Stevan, 2­66, 4­62
Haugeland, John, 3­95, 4­67
Hayes, Patrick J., 3­84
Heidegger, Martin, 3­39, 3­40, 3­125
Hempel, Carl, 1­118, 1­120
Hilf, F., 2­5
Hinton, George, 3­21, 5­77, 5­78
Hobbes, Thomas, 7­106
Hodgson, Shadworth, 6­77
Hofstadter, Douglas, 1­69, 1­70, 1­71, 1­73, 1­74, 1­75, 1­76, 1­77, 1­106, 5­59, 5­84, 7­50, 7­64, 7­70
Holyoak, Keith, 1­72
Hook, Sydney, 6­14
Horgan, Terence, 5­27, 5­28, 5­29, 5­40
Husserl, Edmund, 4­16, 6­85
Hutton, Anthony, 7­62
Hsu, Feng-hsiung, 3­67

Jackson, Frank, 6­58
Jackson, Stuart, 5­37
Jacquette, Dale, 4­58, 4­71, 4­73, 4­75, 4­77, 4­81, 7­88
Jahren, Neil, 4­90, 4­91
Jaki, Stanley L., 1­63, 6­5
James, William, 3­66, 6­78
Jefferson, Geoffrey, 1­37, 6­10
Johnson-Laird, Philip, 1­6, 1­54, 1­108, 6­21

Kant, Immanuel, 3­55, 7­108, 7­114, 7­115
Karelis, Charles, 2­48, 2­49, 2­50, 2­107
Kelly, Kevin, 7­28
Kierkegaard, Søren, 3­83
Klein, Sheldon, 1­113
Kosslyn, Stephen, 5­76, 5­79, 5­80, 5­81, 5­87, 5­90, 5­92, 5­96, 5­99, 5­100, 5­102, 5­103, 5­105, 5­111,
Kraemer, H., 2­5

Laird, John, 3­70
Lakoff, George, 3­43, 3­71, 3­72, 3­91, 3­94, 3­104, 3­105, 3­106, 5­58
Langley, P., 1­122
Lashley, K., 6­73
Ledergerg, J., 1­124
Lee, John R. E., 3­4, 3­54
Leiber, Justin, 2­31
Leibniz, Gottfried, 6­55, 7­118, 7­119
Lenat, Douglas, 3­87, 3­89, 3­99
Lepore, Ernie, 6­92, 6­96
Lettvin, J. Y., 3­112
Levine, Joseph, 5­67
Lewis, David, 7­12, 7­14
Lighthill, James, 3­74, 3­90, 3­92
Lloyd, Dan, 5­67
Locke, John, 3­31, 6­20
Loebner, Hugh, 2­19
Lowenheim, Leopold, 3­107
Lucas, John, 6­54, 7­3, 7­6, 7­9, 7­13, 7­16, 7­17, 7­19, 7­22, 7­34, 7­37, 7­42, 7­43, 7­46, 7­47, 7­49, 7­58, 7­59, 7­60, 7­63, 7­68, 7­75, 7­76
Lyngzeidetson, Albert E., 7­44, 7­83

MacLennan, Bruce, 7­52
Maloney, J. Christopher, 4­45, 4­46, 4­87
Mangan, Bruce, 6­49
Marr, David, 5­75
Martin, J. E., 7­71
Masterman, Margaret, 1­109
Matthews, Robert, 5­47
Maturana, Humberto, 3­111, 3­112
Maudlin, Tim, 6­40, 6­43, 6­44, 6­45, 6­46, 6­47, 6­48
McCarthy, John, 3­69, 3­75, 3­77, 3­79, 3­80, 3­84,5­64
McClelland, James, 3­7, 3­13, 3­16, 3­18, 3­21, 3­52, 5­10, 5­11, 5­22, 5­23
McCulloch, Warren, 3­6, 3­112
McGinn, Colin, 6­64, 6­68
McIntyre, Ronald, 4­16
McLaughlin, Brian,5­36, 5­39, 5­42, 5­45, 5­49, 5­53, 5­55
Meehan, Jim, 1­110
Meltzer, B., 2­29
Mensch, James, 4­17
Merleau-Ponty, Maurice, 3­97
Mill, John Stuart, 6­13
Minsky, Marvin, 1­5, 3­29, 5­10
Mitchell, David B., 5­101
Mitchell, Melanie, 1­77
Moor, James, 2­11, 2­28, 2­53, 2­59, 2­60, 2­77, 2­80, 2­108, 2­110, 4­59, 4­60, 4­98
Moore, Joyce, 3­116
Moore, J. S., 7­56
Moravec, Hans, 1­40
Mortenson, Chris, 5­67
Morton, Adam, 5­67
Myhill, John, 7­81

Nagel, Ernest, 7­82
Nagel, Thomas, 6­59, 6­63
Nelson, Raymond J., 4­29, 4­61, 4­105, 7­94, 7­97
Newell, Allen, 3­2, 3­57, 3­70, 4­2
Newman, James R., 7­82
Newton, Natika, 4­10, 4­11
Nii, P., 1­111
Nishihara, Keith, 5­75
Norvig, Peter, 7­51
Nowatzyk, Andreas, 3­67

Oaksford, Mike, 3­15, 3­24, 5­18
Obermeier, Klaus, 4­79, 4­80
Ortony, A., 1­52

Paivio, Allan, 5­91, 5­94, 5­110
Papert, Seymour, 5­10
Penrose, Roger, 1­84, 5­3, 7­23, 7­27, 7­29, 7­31, 7­53, 7­66
Pfeifer, Karl, 4­66
Pinker, Steven, 5­24, 5­81, 5­90, 5­99, 5­102, 5­105
Pitts, Walter, 3­6, 3­112
Pollock, John, 1­126, 5­43, 6­25, 6­26, 6­34
Pomerantz, James, 5­76, 5­79, 5­80, 5­92, 5­96, 5­111
Port, Robert, 5­12
Post, Emil, 7­80
Prince, Alan, 5­24
Puccetti, Roland, 6­6, 6­74
Putnam, Hilary, 1­22, 1­24, 1­32, 2­86, 6­9, 6­16, 6­32, 6­38, 6­67, 7­84
Pylyshyn, Zenon, 3­10, 3­11, 3­14, 3­19, 3­23, 3­53, 3­60, 3­98, 3­118, 5­16, 5­17, 5­31, 5­44, 5­89, 5­93, 5­95, 5­97, 5­106, 5­108, 5­112, 5­114

Quarnton, Gardner, 5­67
Quine, W. V. O., 4­104

Rapaport, William, 1­64, 4­89, 4­92
Reinhardt, William Nelson, 7­121
Rey, Georges, 1­33, 4­97, 5­67, 6­23
Reznick, J. Steven, 5­101
Richardson, Robert, 2­91, 2­106
Richman, Charles L., 5­101
Rollins, Mark, 5­98, 5­114
Rosch, Eleanor, 3­85
Rosenbloom, Paul, 3­70
Rosenblueth, Arturo, 3­27
Rosenfield, Ronald, 5­15
Rosenthal, Daniel, 6­24
Roskies, Adina, 7­26
Rueckl, Jay, 5­67
Rumelhart, David, 3­7, 3­13, 3­16,3­18, 3­21, 3­52, 5­10, 5­11, 5­22, 5­23
Russell, Stuart, 7­51
Russell, Bertrand,6­15
Russow, Lily-Marlene, 4­35
Rychlak, Joseph F., 1­26, 1­35, 2­55, 2­56, 3­25, 3­26, 3­28, 3­29, 3­30, 3­45, 4­52, 5­84, 5­85
Ryle, Gilbert, 2­85

Savitt, Steven, 4­69
Scheines, Richard, 1­119
Schneider, Walter, 5­60, 5­67
Schwartz, Stephen P., 5­81, 5­90, 5­99, 5­102, 5­105
Scriven, Michael, 1­41
Searle, John, 1­79, 1­81, 2­23, 2­54, 2­79, 4­3, 4­4, 4­5, 4­6, 4­7, 4­9, 4­12, 4­13, 4­14, 4­18, 4­25, 4­27, 4­31, 4­36, 4­53, 4­54,
Seidenberg, Mark, 5­25, 5­26
Shankar, Natarajan, 7­55
Shanon, Bennie, 2­30, 2­32
Sharkey, Noel, 5­37
Sharrock, Wes, 3­4, 3­54
Sharvy, Richard, 4­19, 4­33, 4­100, 4­101, 4­102, 4­103
Shieber, Stuart, 2­15, 2­16, 2­17, 2­18, 2­20
Simon, Herbert, 1­86, 1­122, 3­2, 3­20, 3­57, 3­115, 3­117, 3­119, 3­121, 3­123, 4­2
Simons, Geoff, 1­5, 1­7, 1­8, 1­18, 1­57, 1­58
Skarda, Christine A., 3­34, 3­36, 5­14
Skolem, Thoraf, 3­107
Sloman, Aaron, 1­34, 1­50, 1­55, 1­56, 4­32
Smart, J. J. C., 1­30, 1­31, 7­39, 7­40, 7­41, 7­86, 7­87
Smart, Ninian, 1­4, 1­20
Smith, D. H., 1­124
Smith, George E., 5­81, 5­90, 5­99, 5­102, 5­105
Smolensky, Paul, 5­35 , 5­38, 5­57, 5­63, 5­65, 5­68
Solomon, Martin K., 7­83
Spinoza, Benedict, 7­113
Stalker, Douglas, 2­109
Stanovich, Keith, 1­85
Stevenson, John, 2­9
Stonier, Tom, 1­39
Strom, John, 3­62
Stone, Gregory, 5­67
Stubenberg, Leopold, 6­27
Suchman, Lucille, 3­124
Swagerman, Jaap., 1­51

Thagard, Paul, 1­72, 4­88
Thompson, Dennis, 6­17, 6­69,
Thompson, Evan, 3­85
Tienson, John, 5­27, 5­28, 5­29, 5­40
Touretsky, David, 5­15, 5­67
Tulving, Endel, 6­4
Turing, Alan, 1­1, 1­9, 1­59, 1­60, 1­61, 1­62, 1­87, 1­88, 1­89, 1­90, 1­91, 1­92, 1­93, 1­94, 1­95, 1­96, 1­98, 1­99, 1­100, 1­101, 1­102, 1­104, 2­1, 2­2, 2­3, 2­25, 2­26, 2­77, 3­1, 3­47, 3­48, 4­1, 5­1, 6­1, 6­11, 7­1, 7­79, 7­90
Tye, Michael, 5­71, 5­72, 5­73, 5­74,
Tymoczko, Thomas, 7­73, 7­85

Van De Vate, Dwight, 1­128, 1­129, 1­130, 1­131, 6­52
van Gelder, Tim, 5­12, 5­33
Varela, Francisco, 3­85
Vera, Alonso, 3­117, 3­115, 3­119, 3­121, 3­123
von Neumann, John, 3­9

Wang, Hao, 7­15
Webb, Judson, 7­18, 7­20, 7­21, 7­122
Weber, S., 2­5
Weiss, Paul, 1­43
Weizenbaum, Joseph, 2­34
White, W. C., 1­124
Whitely, C. H., 7­69
Wiener, Norbert, 3­27
Wilensky, Robert, 4­37
Wilkes, Kathleen, 6­81
Wilks, Yorick, 4­26
Winograd, Terry, 3­110, 3­111|
Wittgenstein, Ludwig, 3­51, 6­75
Woodfield, Andrew, 5­67

Ziff, Paul, 1­19, 1­21, 1­23, 1­29, 6­3
Zytkow, Jan, 1­122